4. A Heart That Can Begin Again

12 minutes ago

4 min read

Psalm 51 — Repentance

I have friends in recovery who talk about taking a personal inventory. They look back over their lives and name the harm they have caused: the lies, the broken promises, the relationships damaged, the people let down. It means going back over things they might rather forget, and being honest about the part they played.

There is something courageous about this. Not because it makes for a good story, or because the past can somehow be put right, but because it means no longer hiding from the truth. Sometimes there are amends to make, apologies to offer, relationships to repair. Sometimes the people we have hurt are no longer there, or the damage cannot be undone. We cannot change what happened. We can begin to take responsibility for it.

There are things that have been done to us, and things we have done to others. Sometimes the two are tangled together. We may carry wounds from our past while knowing that we have left wounds of our own. It can be easier to speak about the first than the second.

Psalm 51 is a prayer from someone who has run out of excuses.

The psalm is traditionally associated with David after the prophet Nathan confronts him about his adultery with Bathsheba and the killing of her husband, Uriah. Nathan tells David a story that exposes the truth of what he has done. David’s response is brief: “I have sinned against the Lord.” His actions were not simply a private moral failure. Other lives were caught up in them, and others suffered because of his abuse of power as king. His repentance has to begin with facing that truth.

“Create in me a pure heart, O God, and renew a steadfast spirit within me.” — Psalm 51:10 (NIV)

The psalmist does not simply ask to feel better. He asks for a new heart. He knows that something has gone wrong deep within him, something that another promise or a fresh start of his own making cannot quite reach. He needs God to do in him what he cannot do for himself.

Not a better excuse.

Not another promise.

Not a fresh coat of paint

over the cracks.

A new heart.

Something only God

can create.

We can know we need to change and still find ourselves unable to make that change last. We can see the patterns that keep bringing harm, yet find ourselves caught in them again. The desire to be different is there, but desire alone is not enough.

And here we come to the mystery of grace.

Jesus tells a story about a son who leaves home for a far country. He wastes what he has been given and eventually finds himself hungry, ashamed and alone. He begins to make his way back, rehearsing the words he will say. He knows he has done wrong. He is not returning with a list of excuses.

But while he is still a long way off, his father sees him and runs to meet him.

The father has not stopped being his father.

The son has travelled far, but he has not travelled beyond the reach of his father’s love. Before the speech is finished, before anything has been repaired, the father has welcomed him home.

The far country

is further than we imagined.

The road home

longer than we hoped.

But somewhere

beyond our rehearsed apologies,

there is a father

running towards us.

This is not a story in which wrongdoing does not matter. The son has squandered what he was given. His choices have consequences. But the father’s mercy is not a prize for getting everything right. It is waiting for him before he has managed to put his life back together.

We do not repent in order to persuade God to be merciful. We can repent because mercy has already made a way home.

I think of it as mercy east of Eden.

East of the garden, we live in a world marked by estrangement. Trust is broken. Shame takes root. We hurt one another, and sometimes we find ourselves living with the consequences for years. We can become strangers to the people we love, to the person we hoped to be, even to ourselves. There are roads we wish we had never taken, and things we cannot undo.

Yet east of Eden, the road home is not closed.

Coming home is not always easy. Forgiveness does not automatically restore trust. An apology cannot demand that someone else is ready to forgive. There may be a long way to travel, and some things we have broken cannot be put back as they were. Repentance asks us to face that truth, not turn away from it.

But shame need not have the final word. We are not required to remain forever the person we were at our worst. The psalmist asks for a clean heart because he believes that God can create something new within him.

At Lighthouse, we meet people who carry deep shame, sometimes for what has been done to them, sometimes for what they have done, and often for both. We need to be able to tell the difference. No one should be made to carry blame for the harm others have caused them. And where we have caused harm ourselves, we need the courage to face it honestly.

The son has to turn around and begin the journey home. But he does not have to make himself worthy of being loved before he sets out. That is the extraordinary thing about the father’s welcome.

Psalm 51 gives us words for this journey. It is a prayer for more than relief from guilt. It asks for a heart that can love differently, live differently, and begin again.

Question to carry: Is there something you need to face honestly, and can you trust that God’s mercy meets you there?

Prayer

Create in me a clean heart, O God.

Give me the courage

to face what I have done,

and the humility

to make amends where I can.

Where I have hurt others,

keep me from making excuses.

Where shame has taken hold,

help me not to lose hope.

I have travelled far.